Proposals & Concepts

06
Jul

2018

Hanoi’s Red River Gondola Proposal

Mr. Ngo Manh Tuan, Deputy Director of the Hanoi Department of Transportation wants to carefully assess and evaluate the gondola concept that was submitted this week. Image by elevonic.

The Vietnamese capital of Hanoi has received a proposal to build an urban gondola across the Red River. Based on articles found online (Vietnam Biz, VTN and Moi Truong), the ropeway system is apparently 5km (3mi) in length and is designed to transport 3,500-4,500 persons per hour per direction onboard a fleet of 25/30-passenger cabins. While the technology was not mentioned, the proposed system may likely use 3S technology given the cabin capacities stated and the potential spans required.

The current concept is to have a ropeway travel over the Red River at heights of 50-100m (160-320ft) while connecting Long Bien Bus Station to Gia Lam Bus Station. Proponents hope that the cable car will relieve traffic congestion and reduce cross-river travel times.

The gondola could be a welcome addition to Hanoi as its rapid transit network is highly underdeveloped for a city with 7.5 million residents. At this time, the capital has zero subway lines (the first urban rail line won’t begin trial operations until August) and its public transit network is merely composed of 100 bus routes. Many, if not most, residents still rely upon the city’s five million motorbikes for daily transport.

The motorbikes can be an efficient (and thrilling) way to move about the city, but officials are hoping to ban their use by 2030 in order to reduce environmental and traffic congestion problems. As such, an urban ropeway with its electric propulsion systems and small footprint, could potentially reduce gridlock, lower greenhouse gas emissions, and provide commuters with an alternative mode of transport.

While cable transit solutions have yet to be implemented in Vietnamese cities, the country is already home to some of the world’s most technologically advanced ropeways. In total, the country holds multiple world records which include:

  1. Longest 3S cable car: Hon Thom-Phu Quoc Cable Car at 7.9km
  2. Second longest 3S cable car: Fansipan Legend at 6.3km
  3. Longest continuous MDG: Bana Hills Cable Car at 5.8km
  4. Largest ropeway cabin: Queen Cable Car at 230 persons
  5. Tallest ropeway tower: Queen Cable Car at 188.8m

Vietnam features some of the globe’s most impressive aerial ropeways. These include the Hon Thom 3S (top left), Fansipan Legend (top right), Bana Hills MDG (bottom left) and the Queen Cable Car (bottom left). Images by pduyma, Viwikipediaorg, vtt, and Newone.

Despite the success of these recreational ropeways, the reaction to the Hanoi proposal appears to be mixed at this time. The Hanoi Automobile Transport Association has apparently said that cable lifts are not suitable for public transit while local transport expert, Dr. Nguyen Xuan Thuy, expressed concerns over a ropeway’s ability to reduce traffic congestion. Of course, these comments are expected with any proposal and they appear to be nothing more than a knee-jerk reaction from those who are unfamiliar with the technology.

For professionals who have followed Cable Propelled Transit (CPT), they will know that over 35 public transit gondolas are now operational worldwide while cable cars have been well-documented in terms of its ability to reduce gridlock. For instance, the Mexicable is estimated to have removed 5,800 vehicles from local roadways, while the Mi Teleferico has eliminated the consumption of over 3,000,000 litres of gasoline per year.

Other local experts, such as Dr. Nguyen Huu Nguyen (Urban Planning Association of Vietnam) and Associate Professor Tu Sy Sy (Hanoi University of Transport) have taken a more open-minded position. They have noted the long and proven track record of the ropeway industry, the large capacities of the cabins (nearing the size of a small bus at 25-30 persons) and the ability of ropeways to easily traverse difficult topography. Officials have also acknowledged their wish to objectively assess the submission and determine if the concept is suitable for the city.

With this proposal, Hanoi appears to be the second Vietnamese city to have an urban gondola plan announced publicly. In a separate project last year, a developer in Ho Chi Minh City was unable to advance an aerial lift idea to connect two parks and the Tan Son Nhat international airport. As more Asian cities are now exploring the feasibility of Cable Propelled Transit, the implementation of an urban gondola in Vietnam could help further cement the country as a hub for ropeway innovation.



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

21
Jun

2018

Amsterdam is Getting Serious About An Urban Gondola

Rendering of the IJbaan Cable Car. Looking northbound from Minerhaven Station to NDSM Marina Station. Image by UN Studios.

After three years of research, community outreach, and concept development, designs for a 1.5km urban gondola in Amsterdam were released last week. The cable car project has been spearheaded by locals Bas Dekker and Willem Wessels, who appears to have support from the City of Amsterdam, Port of Amsterdam (Dutch: Haven van Amsterdam) and the Amsterdam Transport Region (Dutch: Vervoerregio Amsterdam).

Since the gondola is designed to cross the IJ, Amsterdam’s waterfront, the system has been aptly named the IJbaan (i.e. a cable car is called kabelbaan in Dutch, so IJbaan, presumably means IJ cable car).

Based on the proposed alignment, the ropeway’s northern terminal, NDSM Marina, is located in the Amsterdam-noord borough while the system’s southern terminal, Minerhaven, is located in the Amsterdam-West borough. NDSM Marina Station has been designed as a transport hub with bike facilities, bus connections and an observation deck. Minerhaven Station, on the other hand, has been planned as a neighbourhood plaza complete with a restaurant and bar.

NDSM Marina Station. Image by UN Studios.

While it appears that most online articles has yet to reveal the technology choice, the renderings make it quite clear that the team has chosen a 3S system. Proponents have estimated ride times at 4.6 minutes, travel speeds at 6m/s (21.6km/h) and cabin sizes at 32-37 persons (with enough room to fit 4-6 bicycles). Initial ridership is projected at 4,000 daily passengers while up to 10,000 riders per day may be transported by 2040.

If you feel that you’ve seen the Amsterdam proposal before, you’re not far off. The architects behind the IJbaan, UN Studios, were the team behind the winning proposal for the Gothenburg Cable Car in Sweden. Image by UN Studios.

Along the journey, passengers will travel over three customized towers which have been designed to pay homage to the city’s industrial heritage. Riders will likely get incredible panoramic views of the city’s waterfront as the three towers will be 46m to 136m tall.

If built, the middle tower  (136m) will be one of the tallest ropeway towers in the world — only surpassed by approximately three other systems (e.g. Ha Long Bay Queen Cable Car – 188m, Phu Quoc Cable Car – 160m, and Zugspitze Eibsee Cable Car – 127m).

Compared to other Cable Propelled Transit (CPT) lines, the Amsterdam proposal may very well have the world’s tallest urban cable car tower.

For instance, urban gondolas with tall towers, such as the Emirates Air Line Cable Car and Nizhny Novgorod Cable Car have tower heights of just 90m and 82m respectively.

It appears that the proponents have spent considerable time thinking through the proposal as they’ve designed it to expand to a three-station system in the future.

Phase 1 would see the aforementioned 1.5km connection built between NDSM Marina Station and Minerhaven Station by 2025 while Phase 2 would see the system expand southwest for another ~800m to Hemknoop Station.

Proponents have described the cable car as an “air bridge” with the ability to complement Amsterdam’s goals of not only becoming a hub for urban innovation but to build an all electric public transit system. While the system has been estimated to cost US$105mm (€90mm), this will still be less than building a comparable bridge.

If everything goes according to plan, the cable car will be up and running by Amsterdam’s 750th anniversary in 2025. In total, this means that in Europe alone, nearly 70 urban cable cars have now been proposed on the continent.



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

08
Jun

2018

Eleven Kilometers of 3S Gondola Announced in Santo Domingo

A 11km cable car proposal was announced during a groundbreaking ceremony for the Intercity Cibao bus terminal. Image by PresidencyRD.

The capital of the Dominican Republic has revealed their plans to construct the city’s second urban gondola — the Santo Domingo West Cable Car (Spanish: Teleférico de Santo Domingo Oeste).

Unlike the city’s first Cable Propelled Transit (CPT) line — the Santo Domingo Cable Car (Spanish: Teleférico de Santo Domingo) — this new ropeway proposal would result in the construction of a massive 6-station 3S gondola which would span 11km (6.8mi) and connect three municipalities in the city’s westside (i.e. Los Alcarrizos, Santo Domingo Este and Distrito Nacional).

Effectively, the 3S urban ropeway adds to the recent flurry of transportation projects unveiled in Santo Domingo. Some readers might recall that the city’s current gondola was just inaugurated less than three weeks ago. While the first Santo Domingo Cable Car is an impressive system itself, measuring in at 5km (3.1mi)with 4-stations, the proposed 3S will more than double its length.

Officials informed the public that the six stations will be built at Puente Blanco, the Intercity Cibao transport terminal, Monumental Ave, Manoguayabo and Prolongación Ave, Kilometre 9 and Duarte Highway, and Herrera.

Route alignment for 6-station Santo Domingo West Cable Car delineated in teal while the 4-station Santo Domingo Cable Car is drawn in green. The 3S system is designed to connect to the Maria Montez Metro station on Line 2 (Orange Line) at the 3S’ Kilometre 9 station. Image from Listin Diario.

If the Dominican capital builds their tricable system, it would become the world’s longest 3S gondola — surpassing the current record-holder in Vietnam (7.9km Hon Thom 3S) by more than three kilometres (1.9mi)! Image from Sun World Hon Thom Nature Park.

In comparison to other publicly announced cable transit plans, the only other 3S proposal that would come even close to the size and scale of the Santo Domingo West Cable Car would be the 10km 3S gondola proposed in Istanbul. However, little information about this proposal has been available since it was first publicized in December 2015.

For those still learning the ropes, it’s important to note that 3S gondolas are considered the most advanced cable-driven systems today. With two track ropes and one propulsion rope, 3S gondolas have the highest capacities (up to 6,000 pphpd) and highest wind resistance (>100km/h).

Less than twenty 3S gondolas have been built to date though, with the majority of these systems functioning in ski resorts. As such, if the 11km Santo Domingo West Cable Car was successfully implemented, it could have a massive impact within the urban transport industry. Given the Dominican capital’s proximity to large American and Canadian cities, this 3S gondola could be a major demonstration system for North American transit planners.

Precise specifications for the system will be detailed as technical planning work commences. The President, however, announced that the cable car will be fully integrated with the rest of the city’s transit network and will cost less than US$0.50 (25 pesos). Officials hope that the cable car will benefit upwards of 400,000 residents by the time it opens in 2020.



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

06
Jun

2018

3S Gondola Being Planned to Connect Moscow Metro

The Russian capital is considering a 3S gondola, similar to that seen in Koblenz (pictured above). The proposal hopes to service two districts which are currently separated by the Khimki reservoir. Image by CUP.

At a recent economic forum in St. Petersburg, Russia, the deputy mayor of Moscow announced that the government is in the midst of planning an urban gondola 15km northwest of the city center. Project proponents are envisioning a 2.3km tricable detachable gondola (TDG/3S) which connects Skhodnenskaya Metro station (Line 7) to Rechnoy Vokzal Metro station (Line 2).

At this time, the Khimki reservoir (Moscow Canal) lies in the middle of the two Metro stations which makes travel between the stations incredibly challenging and time-consuming.

Basically this means it takes up to 45 minutes (10km) by road to travel between Yuzhnoye Tushino District (Skhodnenskaya station) and the Levoberezhny District (Rechnoy Vokzal station) despite the fact that the two areas are just separated by a few hundred meters of water.

Green route illustrates gondola alignment over the Khimki reservoir. Existing transport route via road transport is shown in the blue line. Screenshot from mu24.

With the proposed US$64 million (4 billion rubles) 3S gondola, the city hopes to cut travel times down to seven minutes for an estimated 19,000 daily passengers while reducing the amount of road congestion.

It appears that the system may be built under a Public Private Partnership (PPP) structure where the city is only involved in providing the land for construction. The private sector partner, meanwhile, will be responsible for building and operating the cable car over a 22 year concession. Officials hope to connect the gondola with the rest of Moscow’s transit fare payment system, Troika.

While urban gondolas are still a fairly new concept in modern Russia, Nizhny Novgorod (400km east of Moscow) has operated a river-crossing gondola since 2011 while an upcoming recreational cable car (Vorobyovy Gory to Luzhniki Stadium) is expected to begin commercial service this year in Moscow.

The city and its partners hope that they can open the 3S gondola between Skhodnenskaya station to Rechnoy Vokzal station within three years.



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

29
May

2018

Tokyo 2020 Olympics: Urban Gondola Set to Return to Yokohama

The proposed Yokohama gondola could look similar to the Lisbon Telecabine which is built alongside the Tagus river in the Park of the Nations district. Image by Nicholas Chu.

Proposals for a 2020 Tokyo Olympics urban gondola was first broached in April 2014 but little information on its alignment and location was available at that time.

This week however, Japan Times announced that a 600m cable transport line is now being planned in Yokohama which connects JR Sakuragicho Station to the Minato Mirai 21 district. If built, Tokyo will join London as the second city in recent memory to construct a gondola system in anticipation of a Summer Olympic games.

Proposed alignment. Image from Hamarepo.

It appears that the city’s Urban Development Bureau released a Request for Proposal in December last year which asked private firms to submit ideas to revitalize the waterfront. A total of ten proposals were submitted which included ideas for water taxis, open top buses and a longer aerial gondola system. However, upon review, city officials chose Senyo Kogyo Co (an amusement operator) to implement the gondola which is designed to travel at heights of up to 40m.

Gondola built in 1989 in Yokohama, Japan. Image from kanaloco.

Interestingly, while the idea of a cable lift might seem novel, the Japanese port city actually built a temporary cable lift back in 1989 as part of the Yokohama Exotic Showcase (YES’ 89).

While it is unclear if this proposal was inspired directly by the Emirates Cable Car in London, the Yokohama system does share some similarities with its English counterpart. This gondola hopes to attract visitors and improve connectivity while using the gondola as a catalyst to spark waterfront revitalization.

At the Mirai Mirao 21 station location, this area is considered the city’s central business district where a number of major attractions are currently operational (i.e. Cosmoworld amusement park, Landmark Tower skyscraper, Cup Noodles Museum and the Red Brick Warehouse shopping center).

If the system is designed well and learns from best practices of previous urban cable cars, the gondola could be a welcome addition and great complementary attraction in Yokohama as the city already attracts a staggering 36.3 million annual visitors.



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

11
Apr

2018

Gothenburg Cable Car in 3D


Bit by bit, the proposal for the Gothenburg Cable Car is starting to take shape.

After a panel of judges selected the winners of its cable car design competition in February, the team behind what may be Sweden’s first Cable Propelled Transit (CPT) system has produced a fantastic 3D animation of the twelve minute aerial ride.

Over the years, we’ve seen many thoughtful and well-meaning proposals. However, when it comes to developing a well-coordinated and comprehensive project development plan, the Gothenburg proposal really stands head and shoulders above its competitors.

From the aforementioned design competition, the project team has incorporated many unique ideas to not only build support for the proposal, but to engage the local community in a fully transparent and interactive manner. To name a few memorable items, the team have designed 360 degree videos (see below), hands-on information booths with 3D goggles, and an informative website.


The development team behind the proposal has undoubtedly done their homework and aspiring CPT project proponents would be wise to learn and integrate some of these best practices into their proposals. If the project continues to hit its targeted timelines, the cable car should be operational by the time the City celebrates its 400th birthday in 2021.



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

360° Videos / Gothenburg Cable Car
Comments Off on Gothenburg Cable Car in 3D
Comments Off on Gothenburg Cable Car in 3D
20
Mar

2018

Interview on Edmonton’s Urban Gondola Project

Edmonton Gondola Rendering. Image from CBC.

In the last few weeks, interest in urban gondolas has skyrocketed as two major proposals simultaneously made headlines in North America. In Canada, the Edmonton River Valley Gondola was selected as the winner of a local design competition while the Boston Seaport Gondola proposal was revised and re-released for public consumption.

As part of the general discourse, Gondola Project’s founder, Steven Dale, was recently featured and interviewed by Laura Lynch on CBC Radio. In the eight minute conservation, Steven gives his insight on the state of Cable Propelled Transit (CPT) and why a gondola in Edmonton might make a lot of sense. In addition, you can also hear project proponent, Amber Polyquin’s thoughts on how the proposal was developed.

For those new to the website, please feel free to browse around, ask questions and explore why the idea of using gondolas as urban transport might not be as wacky as you think. In the links below, we’ve compiled a few posts and articles to get you started:

  • Our original blog post on Medellin and Caracas contains a lot of great background information on the evolution and growth of urban cable cars.
  • The world of ropeways can be confusing at first. Take time to learn about the differences between an MDG gondola, a 3S gondola and an Aerial Tram. While these technologies share similarities, their performance capabilities can vary considerably.
  • Understand that we’re not gondola zealots. We don’t see gondolas as the be-all and end-all of public transit. We simply see it as one among many transportation tools. You’ll find us to be highly critical when we need to be.
  • And lastly, be sure to check out how the Edmonton gondola won the competition in the YouTube video below

 



Want more? Purchase Cable Car Confidential: The Essential Guide to Cable Cars, Urban Gondolas & Cable Propelled Transit and start learning about the world's fastest growing transportation technologies.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Boston Seaport Gondola / Edmonton River Valley Gondola
Comments Off on Interview on Edmonton’s Urban Gondola Project
Comments Off on Interview on Edmonton’s Urban Gondola Project